World Economy

(P)GCC States to End Cradle-to-Grave Welfare System

(P)GCC States to End Cradle-to-Grave Welfare System(P)GCC States to End Cradle-to-Grave Welfare System
The IMF says with the introduction of VAT the future looks daunting for the region’s tens of thousands of low-income workers.

Hard hit by a drop in oil income, energy-rich Persian Gulf Arab states will next year introduce value-added tax to a region long known for being tax-free.

Some have hailed introducing VAT as the start of “exciting, dramatic” change in the region, but the measure is also expected to push prices up for all residents including citizens and low-income workers, AFP reported.

On Sunday, the UAE doubles the price of tobacco and increases soft drink prices by 50%, ahead of the more general VAT on goods and services from January 1.

The UAE is one of the six (Persian) Gulf Cooperation Council states (Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, the United Arab Emirates, Qatar, Bahrain and Oman) to have agreed to introduce VAT at 5% next year as they seek to revitalize their economies.

The UAE and Saudi Arabia have said they will implement VAT from January 1, 2018, while the other (P)GCC states of Bahrain, Kuwait, Oman and Qatar are expected to follow suit during the year.

Economies in the Persian Gulf—home to the world’s biggest exporters of oil and liquefied natural gas—took a major hit after a global supply glut triggered a drop in prices in 2014.

Their balance sheets have remained in the red despite government austerity measures recommended by the International Monetary Fund, including freezing wages, benefits and state-funded projects, cutting subsidies and raising power and fuel prices.

Governments across the Arab region have also drawn hundreds of billions of dollars from their massive sovereign wealth resources in an attempt to curb the deficit. The six states are now taking austerity measures a step further with the plan to introduce VAT, ending their decades-old reputation for being tax havens.

VAT to Push Up Prices

Accounting and consultancy firm Deloitte has said the progressive implementation of VAT from next year “marks the start of some of the most exciting, dramatic and far-reaching socio-economic changes in the region since the discovery of oil” more than half a century ago.

But the move is expected to increase prices across the board including for nationals, who make up roughly half of the (P)GCC’s overall population of 50 million.

Persian Gulf nationals have for decades benefited from a generous cradle-to-grave welfare system, and have largely been spared by austerity measures so far.

VAT, a consumption tax imposed on goods and services, is generally paid by individual consumers to businesses, which then transfer the funds to tax authorities. “Citizens won’t be happy about the price hikes from the VAT. I don’t think it will be acceptable as it will affect people’s budgets,” said Khaled Mohammed, a Saudi working in Dubai’s property sector.

The IMF has insisted the introduction of VAT will not drive away millions of expatriates until now lured by a tax-free environment. But the future looks daunting for the region’s tens of thousands of low-income workers.

“It’s going to be tough for all those who draw small salaries,” said Rezwan Sheikh, an Indian restaurant worker in Dubai.

“We’re already struggling with finances. How much are we going to save after the VAT?” asked Sheikh, who sends most of his salary home to his parents and pregnant wife.

Saudi Arabia and the UAE alone make up 75% of the (P)GCC’s $1.4-trillion economy and are home to 80% of the Persian Gulf population, citizens and expatriates.

Fears of Inflation

Under the agreement between (P)GCC states, some goods and services will be exempt from the tax.

Bryan Plamondon of the US-based IHS Markit Economics says food, education and health care, as well as renewable energy, water, transportation, and technology, are likely to receive preferential treatment.

He estimates that VAT will raise between $7 billion and $21 billion annually—or between 0.5% and 1.5% of GDP. The IMF has said the returns could reach around 2% of GDP.

But inflation rates will also increase. Faisal Durrani, who heads research at Cluttons Dubai, expects inflation to double to 4% in the UAE next year.

Capital Economics has projected Saudi inflation could reach 4.5%, a stark shift from the current 0.4% deflation.


Add new comment

Read our comment policy before posting your viewpoints