61071
The headquarters of Banca Monte dei Paschi di Siena SpA
The headquarters of Banca Monte dei Paschi di Siena SpA

Italy Bad Banks Need to Work Down Bad Loans

Italy Bad Banks Need to Work Down Bad Loans

Fixing a rotten banking sector requires policy makers to deploy three tools in unison—and Italy, like Japan two decades ago, is in danger of coming up short.
In addition to prompt recapitalization and robust, independent supervision, reviving lenders saddled with soured loans means governments must step in with “bad banks” that lift troubled assets off balance sheets, according to a new study by the Brussels-based Bruegel Institute, Bloomberg reported.
The report’s authors, Mark Hallerberg and Christopher Gandrud, look back at rescues of credit cooperatives Tokyo Kyowa and Anzen in the 1990s. They conclude that even when banks have been recapitalized, lack of action to relieve them of non-performing loans means they can still founder, locking the economy into a cycle of weak lending and weak growth. Now, with proposals to create a pan-European bad bank going nowhere, policy makers risk making the same mistake in Italy.
“The problem is not that this combination of policy tools is unknown, but that banks and governments lack incentives to use them in combination,” the authors write. “Italy’s December 2016 package providing €20 billion ($21 billion) for recapitalization of banks is a step in the right direction. Similarly, pressure from the European Central Bank on Italian authorities and on banks to address NPLs is welcome. However, policy tools to manage and dispose of NPLs and, just as importantly, incentives to use them, are lacking.”
Although Japan in the 1990s and Italy now aren’t directly comparable, there are similarities. In Japan, a real-estate bust and a slowing economy meant companies and households increasingly couldn’t pay back loans, and banks were unwilling or unable to take the hit to capital that complete write-offs would have entailed.
Hallerberg and Gandrud write that a spate of public and private-sector recapitalizations and loans—termed hogacho after a traditional way of raising money—failed to break the cycle, even with the presence of a new, independent regulator that encouraged tough revaluations of assets. It wasn’t until the Industrial Revitalization Corporation of Japan began buying up and disposing of distressed loans after 2002 that the healing could begin.

 Banks’ Capacity Erodes
In Italy, the stagnation of productivity and lack of any real economic growth in the past two decades has slowly eroded the capacity of the banks to rehabilitate themselves. The agonies over the state’s rescue attempts for Banca Monte dei Paschi di Siena SpA and other lenders have provided a persistent worry for investors in Europe, without a clear prospect of a solution.
This week, JPMorgan Chase & Co. wrote that investors should sell the senior bonds of Banca Popolare di Vicenza SpA and Veneto Banca SpA because Italy may not win European Union permission to provide aid to the lenders that prevents those bondholders from losses. And even though the Italian state has set aside funds, a pan-European bad bank to finally clean up their balance sheets in a way that doesn’t sink the nation’s creditworthiness seems remote.
Andrea Enria, chairman of the European Banking Authority, has proposed setting up a bloc-wide asset-management company to take over and manage the sell-off of the loans. The regulator’s executive director, Adam Farkas, said last month that a “realistic aim could be to move about a quarter” of all bad loans off banks’ balance sheets.
The ECB, in its role as bank supervisor, has made a concerted effort to get lenders to work through their NPLs and restructure them. But the ECB—unlike the Bank of Japan in the 1990s—can’t use its own funds to assist commercial banks.
Without a breakthrough in NPL management, the authors write, Italy may be heading for a replication of the Japanese experience in which crippled banks contributed to a lost decade of sub-par growth. Italy’s economy has already barely grown since joining the euro in 1999.

Short URL : https://goo.gl/1asTkD
  1. https://goo.gl/BXtWXS
  • https://goo.gl/V77cVk
  • https://goo.gl/r68GyP
  • https://goo.gl/jmmj8x
  • https://goo.gl/Em9UiI

You can also read ...

BIS Cautions CBs Launching Own Cryptocurrencies
A report by the Bank for International Settlements has warned...
Janet Yellen
As the Fed starts unwinding the stimulus it provided to snap...
London, Frankfurt and Paris fluttered between flat to slightly lower after eight days of gains.
Record-high world stocks paused on Tuesday and the dollar...
Norway’s Sovereign Wealth Fund  Hits $1 Trillion
The Norwegian sovereign wealth fund, the largest in the world...
Hungary CB Rate on Hold
The Monetary Council of the National Bank of Hungary, or MNB,...
The IMF could write off its debt and lighten Greece’s burden.
“Beware of Greeks bearing gifts,” wrote the ancient Roman poet...
Kazakh Economy Grows by 4.3%
The economic growth in Kazakhstan was at 4.3% since the...
South Korea to Tighten Home Loan Screening
South Korea’s top financial regulator on Tuesday urged banks...

Add new comment

Read our comment policy before posting your viewpoints

Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.

Trending

Googleplus