Analysts Review Fate of Iranian Nuclear Agreement

Analysts Review Fate of Iranian Nuclear AgreementAnalysts Review Fate of Iranian Nuclear Agreement

A year after Iran and six world powers reached a historic nuclear deal, analysts say it is unlikely the incoming administration of Donald Trump will completely dismantle the agreement, which he described as "the worst deal ever negotiated".

A series of Cabinet appointments, however, have signaled Trump is likely to take a hard line on Tehran, according to an article published by AFP on Sunday.

And that will ratchet up pressure on Iran's President Hassan Rouhani, who is making the nuclear deal a centerpiece of his reelection bid this year.

"Some of the people who are taking office in the executive branch have a long history of being against Iran," said Foad Izadi, a professor of international studies at Tehran University.

"We are going to see a harsher policy toward Iran during the Trump administration."

On Sunday, Iran's top negotiator in the nuclear talks accused Washington of doing "whatever it can to slow down Iran's progress" after the deal.

"In the last 12 months, we have witnessed delays and the disrespecting of promises by the US and some countries. Their hostility increases by the day," Deputy Foreign Minister Abbas Araqchi told reporters.

In confirmation hearings ahead of Trump's January 20 inauguration, several of his Cabinet nominees made clear their opposition to a further softening of ties with Tehran.

Secretary of state-nominee, Rex Tillerson, said he would recommend a "full review" of the nuclear agreement.

Defense secretary-pick, James Mattis, said Washington needed to "live up" to its word on the accord, but also alleged that Iran is "the biggest destabilizing force in the Middle East".

Despite his fierce rhetoric and the views of senior Cabinet members, Trump is not likely to try to reverse the deal, experts say.

  Stupid to Shred Deal

"The situation may become worse, but the [nuclear deal] will not be torn up, simply because that's stupid," said Nasser Hadian, another professor of international relations at Tehran University.

The agreement, which lifted a wide range of international sanctions in exchange for limits on Iran's nuclear program, took effect on January 16, 2016, following years of talks.

Negotiated by Tehran and six world powers, including the United States, Russia and China, the agreement was widely seen as a major victory for international diplomacy.

That would make reneging on the deal nearly impossible and fraught with huge risks, analysts say.

"Even the American hawks are all saying don't tear it up," Hadian said.

Instead, he believes, the Trump administration is likely to put pressure on Iran in areas outside the nuclear agreement, including with more sanctions based on its human rights record, ballistic missile program and alleged support for "terrorism" in the Middle East.

That may be bad news for Rouhani who is hoping to point to the agreement and the resulting opening up to the outside world as he seeks reelection in a presidential vote in May.

Rouhani, a moderate, managed to push through the deal despite vocal opposition from domestic opponents, largely by touting its potential economic benefits for Iranians stung by years of sanctions.

In some areas, the deal has started paying off.

Iran more than doubled its oil exports to more than 2.5 million barrels per day last year, earning $29 billion in the nine months leading to December 20.

Energy giants, including France's Total and Anglo-Dutch Shell, are lining up to seek oil and gas deals, and manufacturing has been given a boost with the return of France's PSA, which operates joint ventures with local carmakers.

The lifting of sanctions also allowed the signing of two huge contracts for the purchase of 100 aircraft from European aerospace giant Airbus and another 80 from US rival Boeing.

  Not All Hopes Materialized

Nevertheless, ordinary Iranians have yet to see much improvement in their daily lives.

While the economy grew by 6% between March and September last year and inflation was brought back below 10%, joblessness continues to rise, with 12.7% of the working population unemployed.

Among those under 29, more than a quarter are out of work.

Many Iranians believed the nuclear agreement would see a surge in economic activity, including foreign investments, "but a lot of those hopes have not materialized", Izadi said.

Iranian officials have accused Washington of failing to abide by the spirit of the deal, including with a raft of other sanctions related to non-nuclear issues that have helped deter major western banks from returning to Iran.

Hadian said Rouhani had "oversold" the agreement by telling supporters: "If we have the deal, the next day sanctions are going to be removed and investments" will pour in.

"But he knew that this was impossible and will take time. The opposition is using that to attack the deal."


Add new comment

Read our comment policy before posting your viewpoints